Sunday, May 31, 2009

BBA Challenge Week 3 - Bagels

I don't know if you know this about me, but I love carbs. It's why breakfast is my favorite meal. It's not because of omelets or sausage or bacon. OK, maybe a little about the bacon. No, it's mainly because the entire meal can consist entirely of carbs—pancakes, waffles, hash browns, cereal, cinnamon rolls, toast... and bagels. Ah, bagels. Chewy yet crusty, plain or with a schmear of peanut butter, savory or sweet—although I much prefer sweet, especially if we're talking about breakfast.

I've attempted to make bagels a couple of times and have ended up with something more suitable for a door stop than breakfast. So it was with as much trepidation as anticipation that I approached this week's BBA Challenge bread.

These bagels, as with many of the recipes in Peter Reinhart's book, are a two-day process. The first involves a sponge, waiting, mixing the rest of the ingredients, kneading, dividing, waiting, shaping, waiting and putting in the fridge for an overnight rest. This is called "retarding" the dough so that it has a chance to develop more complex flavors. You can even leave them for a couple of days before proceeding to the next steps.

This? Right here? Breakfast nirvana.

Day one went swimmingly. The sponge got spongy, the dough came together nicely and kneading did its usual trick of making me feel like a strong pioneer woman (not THE Pioneer Woman, more of a "Mrs. Ingalls" kind of pioneer woman). But things weren't looking very promising 10 or 15 minutes into the kneading. I attempted to achieve a "windowpane"— stretching a small portion of dough until it's transcluscent—but mine kept tearing. I kept up the kneading for another 10-15 minutes, but it didn't seem to help.

So I did what any self-respecting home baker would do and gave up. Threw in the towel, hung up my apron. Kidding. I did give up kneading, but continued with the rest of the process, weighing hunks of dough so that each was approximately 4.5 ounces. I ended up with 11 full size and one around 3 ounces. I covered them with a damp towel and let them rest for 20 minutes while I poured myself a glass of wine and hoped for the best.

Measured and shaped rolls, ready for a nice rest.

Next came the shaping. Resting the dough worked some sort of miracle, because the dough seemed just about perfect. I turned each roll into a rope, wrapped it around my hand and pressed the ends together to form the circles. I was feeling much better about the whole thing while letting the shaped bagels rest for another 20 minutes.

At this point, you have to do the float test. If a bagel floats in a bowl of water, you're ready put them in the fridge. My test bagel floated like a champ, so into the fridge they went. And I had another glass of wine.

Day two: boiling and baking. A straightforward day, consisting of—you guessed it—boiling and baking. It wasn't until I snapped my first picture that I realized I'd forgotten to put the baking soda in the pot of boiling water. A mistake easily corrected.

The bagels boil one minute for each side, then you slide them back onto the baking sheets and top with whatever strikes your fancy. I opted for sesame seeds, poppy seeds, and garlic for the savory ones. The rest were either straight turbinado sugar or cinnamon sugar. LOTS of cinnamon sugar. I was going for a Panera-esque look and taste for those. Unfortunately, my heavy-handed sugaring lead to my overly sensitive smoke alarm going off three times while the sugar overflow melted on the baking sheet.

Just-boiled and ready for some toppings.

As a result, I think I undercooked them a bit. The bagels were done, but the crusts weren't browned enough. Didn't stop me from consuming two of them as soon as they were cool enough to eat without burning my mouth.

Get a look at that crumb. Looks like a real bagel and everything.

The verdict: A bit too chewy with a not-as-crisp-as-I'd-like-it crust, but utterly delicious. I'll definitely make them again, just adjust the baking time to achieve the proper crust. Given some practice, I think these could rival any bakery-made bagel I've had.

Next week: Schedule some extra gym time, because we're making BRIOCHE!


  1. Your bagels look wonderful...especially those cinnamon-sugar-setting-off-the-smoke-alarm ones!

    And I know what you mean; I'm thinking of starting a running program this week to offset the effects of the brioche.

  2. Those are amazing looking! You are makin' some very tasty looking carbs these days!

  3. ooooohhhhh - I want to come to your house for a snack right now!

  4. Nice looking bagels! I set off the smoke alarm everytime I bake. It's a combination of my less-than-sparkling oven and all these artisan bread recipes that call for a 500-degree oven. My daughter came out of her room the other morning and said, "Dad, if there's ever a fire, I'll probably die in my bed, 'cause I'll think your just baking again."

  5. oh they look great! I made cinnamon sugar also (and I realize I need a new smoke alarm). They were so tasty (well, not cinnamon-sugar doughnut tasty... but still, tasty).

  6. Loved your details.........especially the wine. :)
    Great looking bagels.

  7. Bagels look fantastic. Your idea of breakfast nirvana matches mine. Your latte looks great. What is your foaming method?
    I love all the wine drinkers in this group. We could be friends!

  8. Dianne - Thanks! I plan on trying a super-duper cinnamon one for tomorrow's b-fast. (and I def need to ramp up my workouts!)

    Susie - Thanks! I loves me some carbs. :)

    Barb - Come on over!

    Phyl - Thanks - I LOL at your daughter's comment. I have a feeling this won't be the last time with the smoke alarm! I did buy a new baking stone in anticipation of breads down the road. The one I have now is so dark that it smoke like a you-know-what when it gets really hot!

    Catherine - So tasty! I love cinnamon.

    Susie - What can I say-I like bread AND wine. :)

    Cindy - Thanks! I have a Seaco OdeaGo automatic espresso maker with a frothing wand. It does a great job, but makes a WHOLE lot of foam! I think it would be a hoot to gather all of the BBA-ers together to gab and nosh!

  9. Very funny comment by Gaaarp -- let's hope that doesn't come true! Lovely bagels, btw. Congrats! I'll have to try cinnamon sugar next time...


Thanks for stopping by and leaving a comment! Please note that I moderate comments so yours won't show up right away, but do know that I read all of them!

I will gladly answer any questions you have right here in the comments. If you would prefer a reply back via email, just let me know and include your email address. Or you can email me directly at info_kellyluna {at} frontier {dot} com.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...